Posted July 10, 2025
RAID 0 seems to me as just asking for trouble, and really not worth the risk, especially in home use scenarios and if you're talking of SSDs.
If the supposedly failed drive seems to have raised from the dead, sure, you could use it as backup. Not in a RAID configuration, but just occasionally making a backup, maybe automatically. There's a lot of backup software out there that can make full images, so if anything goes wrong you just boot from the backup drive and it's all the same (be aware that just copying system files over won't allow you to do that, especially since that most probably won't include the hidden boot partition at all), and even the included system image backup tool in Windows generally works well enough and can be used off a running system (on Win 10+, look for "Backup and restore (Windows 7)", deprecated but still there and functional). For everything else, on the other hand, the robocopy tool in Windows really does a pretty good job, just updating what's changed, and can be automated too. But it's a command line tool, so can take a bit of learning to use properly.
If the supposedly failed drive seems to have raised from the dead, sure, you could use it as backup. Not in a RAID configuration, but just occasionally making a backup, maybe automatically. There's a lot of backup software out there that can make full images, so if anything goes wrong you just boot from the backup drive and it's all the same (be aware that just copying system files over won't allow you to do that, especially since that most probably won't include the hidden boot partition at all), and even the included system image backup tool in Windows generally works well enough and can be used off a running system (on Win 10+, look for "Backup and restore (Windows 7)", deprecated but still there and functional). For everything else, on the other hand, the robocopy tool in Windows really does a pretty good job, just updating what's changed, and can be automated too. But it's a command line tool, so can take a bit of learning to use properly.